Email Strategy & DMARC: How to Stay Ahead of Competitors in 2025

There’s a satisfaction in crafting the perfect email. The subject line is sharp but not desperate, the body is concise yet compelling, and the call to action is just persuasive enough. You hit send and assume your audience will be charmed into engagement. And nothing. Silence. Maybe a few grudging clicks, but otherwise, it’s as if your email disappeared into thin air.

For many businesses, this is a familiar scenario. They think email marketing is about crafting the right message when in reality, the bigger battle is getting the message seen at all. The inbox is a hostile place, clogged with promotions, alerts, and the occasional fraudulent attempt to impersonate a well-known brand. If your email isn’t authenticated properly, it could be flagged, ignored, or worse – relegated to the spam folder where email campaigns go to die.

This is where DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance) comes in. Most businesses acknowledge their role in email security, but fewer understand that it’s also a tool to beat the competition. A well-implemented DMARC policy ensures not only that your emails are protected from impersonation but also that they actually reach inboxes – where they can do their job. And when paired with a competitor analysis tool, you can see how your email strategy stacks up against others in your industry.

The Building Blocks of a Winning Email Strategy

An effective email strategy is not just about writing a clever subject line—it’s about trust, visibility, and authentication. No matter how strong your message is, if it doesn’t get to the inbox or is viewed as untrustworthy, it’s already a failure.

Sender reputation is at work here. Email providers weigh in on engagement, spam complaints, and bounce rates to determine whether your emails deserve an inbox prime spot or a one-way trip to spam. If your domain’s reputation is terrible, even your best-designed email may never get read. A strong email strategy ensures your messages not only resonate with your audience but also reach their inboxes.

Authentication is a make-or-break component, too. DMARC, SPF, and DKIM tell email providers that your messages are real, protecting your brand from spoofing and increasing deliverability. A rival that enforces strong authentication requirements will always have an advantage, while businesses that ignore these procedures can be filtered out entirely.

Key Components of Email Strategy

Effective email strategy isn’t guessing—it’s a process that optimizes content, timing, segmentation, and technical adjustments.

Deliverability and Authentication

Emails that don’t land in your customers’ inboxes are missed opportunities for growth and success. Practicing strong email authentication with DMARC, SPF, and DKIM ensures messages are trusted and spam complaints are reduced. Bounce rate tracking further keeps deliverability on course.

Content and Personalization

Generic emails get ignored. Tailoring content based on audience behavior—whether through A/B-tested subject lines, dynamic content, or segmented messaging—boosts engagement and makes emails feel relevant rather than intrusive.

Timing and Frequency

Send too often, and you’re annoying; too rarely, and you’re forgotten. Analyzing when recipients are most active helps refine send times, ensuring emails land when they’re most likely to be opened.

Segmentation and Targeting

Not all subscribers are the same. Behavior-based segmentation—new leads, repeat buyers, or inactive users—allows for targeted messaging that resonates and doesn’t vanish into thin air.

Analytics and Optimization

Email marketing is an ongoing process. Watching open rates, clicks, and conversions helps fine-tune strategy so that each campaign builds on the success of the last. Firms that adapt continuously stay in front, whereas others threaten to wind up in inbox nowhere.

The Silent Killer of Email Campaigns: Deliverability

The assumption that emails just “arrive” where you sent them is a dangerous one. Email providers, especially the big ones, have sophisticated filters in place to protect users from spam, scams, and phishing attempts. This is great for the recipient but a nightmare for businesses. If your emails fail authentication checks, they may be rejected or quietly buried in the spam folder – unseen and unread.

Factors affecting inbox placement:

• Sender reputation
• Email authentication (DMARC, SPF, DKIM)
• Spam complaints and bounce rates

DMARC, alongside SPF (Sender Policy Framework) and DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), ensures your emails sent from your domain are verified and trusted. Without these protocols in place, your emails can be flagged as suspicious or even blocked entirely. A competitor with a properly authenticated email system will have a much higher chance of reaching inboxes, making their messages visible while yours are lost in digital limbo.

Deliverability isn’t just about security—it’s about visibility. If your emails aren’t reaching your audience, your competitors are getting the advantage by default. Knowing this simple fact separates businesses that struggle with email engagement from those that thrive.

Inbox Placement vs. Open Rates: A Battlefield Few Are Fighting

Most businesses track open rates, click-through rates, and conversions. Fewer track inbox placement rates—the percentage of emails that land in the primary inbox instead of spam or promotional tabs. This is a big oversight.

If a competitor’s emails are consistently landing in the inbox while yours are being marked as untrustworthy, they’ll naturally get more attention from your shared audience. If your competitors have higher engagement rates, it tells the email providers their emails are “wanted,” and they’ll get more deliverability over time.

How DMARC Strengthens Your Email Strategy

This is where DMARC reporting comes in. DMARC gives you visibility into how your emails are being handled by different email providers. If a big chunk of your messages are being rejected or filtered, it’s a warning sign that your domain’s reputation is taking a hit. From here, you can adjust—tighten up your authentication settings, refine your sending habits, and make sure every email is best-practices compliant.

Meanwhile, a competitor that has email deliverability nailed will see higher engagement, a stronger sender reputation, and ultimately more effective marketing campaigns. It’s not just about sending emails—it’s about making sure they’re received, trusted, and engaged with.

Reputation is Everything (and DMARC Protects It)

Reputation in email marketing is not just about branding—it’s a technical score that’s determined by email providers and influenced by how your emails perform. If recipients ignore, delete, or mark your emails as spam, your domain’s reputation will suffer. The worse your reputation, the more likely your emails will be filtered out automatically.

DMARC prevents a silent killer of domain reputation: email spoofing. If cybercriminals use your domain to send fraudulent emails—whether phishing scams or impersonation attempts—recipients who fall for those scams will point the finger at you. Even those who recognize the fraud will associate your domain with suspicion and unreliability. Over time, that erodes trust in your communications and makes recipients less likely to engage with your legitimate emails.

Meanwhile, your competitors—those with strict DMARC enforcement—will never have this problem. Their domains remain clean, their reputations untarnished. Their emails continue to land in inboxes while your brand struggles to recover from association with malicious activity. In a world where trust is currency, failing to protect your domain is the equivalent of handing your competitors a free advantage.

Practical Tips for Email Strategy

A well-structured email strategy isn’t just about sending messages—it’s about sending the right messages at the right time, to the right people, in a way that ensures they’re actually seen. Here’s how to refine each element for maximum impact:

Content: Subject lines and calls to action can make or break engagement. A/B testing different variations helps identify what resonates most, turning guesswork into data-driven decisions.

Timing: Not all audiences check their inboxes at the same time. Analyzing open rates by time of day and day of the week ensures emails land when recipients are most likely to engage.

Segmentation: A one-size-fits-all approach leads to low engagement. Using customer data to tailor content—whether by purchase history, location, or past interactions—makes emails more relevant and effective.

Deliverability: Even the best email is worthless if it never reaches an inbox. Implementing DMARC, SPF, and DKIM protects against impersonation and improves inbox placement, while monitoring bounce rates helps catch issues early.

Analytics: Tracking open rates, click-throughs, and conversions isn’t just about measuring success—it’s about learning. Consistently refining strategy based on performance data ensures campaigns improve over time, keeping you ahead of the competition.

Key Steps to Improve Your Email Strategy with DMARC

1. Authenticate your emails: Implement DMARC, SPF, and DKIM.
2. Monitor domain reputation: Track DMARC reports to identify issues.
3. Optimize email frequency and content: Avoid spam triggers and overloading your audience.
4. Improve segmentation and personalization: Better engagement leads to better deliverability.
5. A/B test subject lines and send times: Refine your strategy based on data-driven insights.

Strategic Insights: What Your Competitors Are Doing Right

Implementing DMARC is not just about protecting your emails—it’s about playing the long game. The businesses that thrive are those that analyze not just their own performance but their competitors’ as well.

Tracking competitor email engagement, deliverability success, and sender reputation can reveal industry benchmarks and hidden weaknesses. If a competitor’s emails are reaching inboxes at a higher rate, they likely have a more effective authentication setup—or a stronger domain reputation. If they are achieving higher open and click rates, it could indicate better timing, subject line optimization, or content relevance.

Use Competitor Analysis to Strengthen Strategy:

Understanding your competitors’ email performance can reveal valuable insights. If their engagement rates are higher, they may be nailing their timing, personalization, or subject lines. If their emails consistently reach inboxes while yours struggle, stronger authentication—such as strict DMARC enforcement—could be the reason. Analyzing their successes (and missteps) helps refine your own approach, ensuring you’re not just keeping up but gaining an edge.

Future-Proofing Your Email Strategy in 2025 and Beyond

Email marketing is evolving, and those who don’t evolve will fall behind. Competitor analysis is a guide to improvement, but so is a willingness to test, refine, and optimize constantly. Asking the right questions—Are my emails sending? Are they opening? —keeps your strategy sharp. Data-driven decision-making, like adjusting send times according to engagement patterns or adjusting content to boost opens, has a measurable effect. And graphics—performance measure charts or infographics describing authentication procedures—help facilitate the translation of insight into action. In order to stand out in a crowded inbox, it’s the winners who marry strategy and adaptability. 

Ready to secure your emails and boost inbox placement? PowerDMARC makes it easy to implement DMARC, SPF, and DKIM, protecting your domain from spoofing and improving deliverability.

Don’t let your emails get lost—start authenticating your domain now. Try PowerDMARC today and stay ahead of the competition!

• About
• Latest Posts

Milena Baghdasaryan

Content Specialist at PowerDMARC

Milena is a skilled writer and content creator with 7+ years of experience in crafting engaging content on IT, cybersecurity, virtual events, and more. She has a proven track record of delivering high-quality work for international magazines and is a graduate of prestigious institutions such as New York University Abu Dhabi, UWC China, and the College of Europe.

Latest posts by Milena Baghdasaryan (see all)

• Email Strategy & DMARC: How to Stay Ahead of Competitors in 2025 - March 10, 2025
• Mastering Email Deliverability: Best Practices for Successful Campaigns - March 5, 2025
• Google Calendar Spoofing: How Attackers Use It for Phishing Scams - March 3, 2025